Where I come from, the law requires my school to do frequent so-called fire drills.
Good thing to do, right? Disaster preparedness? Well, not exactly. Don’t get me wrong, one needs to know what to do should the school catch on fire. But ringing alarms so loudly could be overwhelming to the senses, especially for autistic people and others with sensory processing disorder.
All these years that I’ve been in school, or any place where an alarm bell was near me, I would get so paranoid that it would suddenly blare– and even school counselors agreed that I never know when it could happen– without realizing the seriousness of the trauma I was experiencing.
The school staff’s reasoning for making alarms as loud as they are is that people with Alzheimer’s can’t hear them otherwise. No disrespect to those with Alzheimer’s, but is that really an excuse to make them scream so loud in a children’s school?
Paranoia and Fear About Fire Alarms
Taking it back to what I said about paranoia, absolutely nobody I spoke to about my anxiety and fear of the drills recognized or understood the extent that the fear of a fire alarm impacted my mental health and ability to focus.
It was interfering with my work because every time my teacher was speaking, my fear and feelings of anxiety about an alarm interrupting the lecture were the most brutal. For some reason, during class instruction was the moment when the post traumatic stress hit hardest.
In hindsight, I realize I feared that if I let down my guard enough to focus on the teacher, then the jarring shock of the alarm would be even more traumatic. I was constantly on alert, trying to be prepared for the sound.
That heightened awareness [known as hypervigilance] has led to me missing some important instructions, and then my teachers would scream me out for not paying attention.
Hey, I don’t make the laws!
Trauma Associations from Fire Drills
Even away from school, my intense feelings about the possibility of a fire drill impacted me. The two words fire and drill said together ended up boiling my blood whenever I heard them spoken… or even just the word drill. (Which kind of defeats the whole purpose of a drill).
Our school resource officer then started playing jokes on me by tricking me into thinking there’d be a fire drill, when in fact there wouldn’t be one that day. That was embarrassing. Professional officers aren’t supposed to rub salt in one’s wounds, especially if that someone doesn’t commit crimes.
I didn’t confront her until the the last day of school when we all got sno-cones, and she asked why I didn’t give her one. I then brought up her joking about the fire drills and how much it impacted me and my ability to learn.
But the damage was done. I had learned to fear the alarms far more than I felt a fear of a fire happening in the school. I still battle paranoia in my new apartment with an alarm next to my bedroom door.
Looking into Alternatives for Less Traumatic Fire Drills
I have considered a few potential alternatives. There is already a code set out by the National Fire Protection Association for how loud fire alarms must be, and it is determined by the maximum noise in a building at any time. Alarms must be 15 decibels louder than the ambient sound of a building or 5 decibels above the maximum sound. They are also required to have flashing lights for alerting people who are deaf.
In a factory with a lot of heavy machinery, the sound level would likely be set to the highest decibel rating; however, those employees are often already wearing ear protection. In a quiet apartment complex or office building, the sound level would be much lower.
In a school, the volume is dramatically varied. For example, there is a major difference between a classroom during an exam and a gym during a pep rally or a band room during practice.
So, here are some ideas for making fire drills less stressful. While I don’t think these will eliminate stress, they may be helpful and make schools more inclusive for disabled students and staff. These may involve technology upgrades or approval from the local fire marshal.
- Set the decibel level louder in gyms, band rooms, and the cafeteria and lower in classrooms.
- Measure the volume of the loudest part of the school during the most busy hour and set the alarm no higher than it needs to be.
- Begin the alarm with a quiet sound or with lights only that gradually becomes louder over the course of a few seconds to give students time to protect their ears. This will also reduce how jarring and startling fire drills can be during instruction.
- Gain approval from the fire marshal for reducing the sound level of fire alarms where a visual system would be adequate to alert people of the need to evacuate.
- Switch to a voice-signaling system so evacuation can be directed over the PA system.
None of these are complete solutions, but for autistic students to have access to a free and appropriate education, they need to be able to learn without the fear and trauma of a fire drill. It is a human rights issue when it can cause PTSD and prevent access to learning.
- Abused…at the dentist??? - July 6, 2021
- It was behavior therapy all along, and I had absolutely no clue– until now - March 9, 2021
- Discrimination from DARS: Autism and Seeking Services for Employment - January 9, 2021
I was terrified of fire alarms as a kid, due to an awful night at a hotel where a fire alarm was on the fritz and went off multiple times. Sometime after that incident I went to see 42nd Street on Broadway. There was a sign up outside the stage that said the performance would feature “strobe lights and firearms” but I misread firearms as “fire alarms” and was sitting on the edge of my seat the whole first act. Then came intermission and I re-read the sign. “It’s firearms, not fire alarms!” I thought to myself. “That’s much better.”
I am several decades out of school & fortunately had less trouble with the fire alarms; yet I totally do grasp that concept, “I feared that if I let down my guard enough to focus on the teacher, then the jarring shock of the alarm would be even more traumatic. I was constantly on alert, trying to be prepared for the sound.”
I wonder it it is desired that the alarms are loud and jarring enough to cause people to have an adrenaline hit and get moving.
If that’s the case, it’s been known to work *too* well
In my son’s school, he was removed from class before ANY drill by his one- on- one paraprofessional to a designated space out of the building. He simply could not handle the noise of the alarm, and needed to be forewarned. At 6’7″ and 250 lbs, they did not want to have him react to the alarm because he headed out of the building and towards a major highway in response. His OCD did not allow him to do anything but leave, and they could not stop him physically as he could not understand anything they said because it sounded underwater. Touching him only made things worse. The removal ahead of time was the solution which worked best though it required his para to know about fire drills ahead of time.
Fire drills are probably the #1 time I had to mask and hide my differences in high school because this one bully would always make fun of me for covering my ears at the sound of the fire alarm. He would always angrily yell at me “calm down, it’s just a fire alarm” and of course everyone always took his side and joined in on the bullying. Imagine getting angry at someone else’s sensory issues that don’t impact you negatively in any way.
Stop blaming your kid for the school’s incompetence.